Brunswicks is a specialist law firm offering strategic regulatory advice nationwide.

Making the most of BHCR

BHCR is distributed primarily by email and in pdf form. It is best viewed as a pdf where you will find embedded hyperlinks. We cannot guarantee that these links work or will remain working although they did at the time the edition was first published. This edition of BHCR is reproduced on this web-page. You can re-size the font and use the Search this Site facility to identify useful text. The hyperlinks are not activated directly from this web-page. If you wish to use them you are advised to use the pdf version.

Both editions are © Brunswicks LLP 2008


BHCR 2008 Vol 3 Issue 07

(Click the icon to download)
© Brunswicks LLP 2008

This week's article

Editorial

This past week I attended a meeting with my fellow

trustees of Action on Elder Abuse – a hugely

worthwhile charity focused on raising awareness of

abuse of older people and making society intolerant

of such behaviours.

As we closed our meeting a call came through for

one of the executives who was being contacted by a

television researcher for first impressions and

quotable quotes on a story being given front page

profile by The Daily Mail on its website.

The story, at item 80, is shocking and has received

wide press coverage.

However, what I find more shocking is the apparent,

almost indifference, displayed sometimes by social

services.

I am involved in a matter where photographs were

taken, using a mobile camera ‘phone, of the genitalia

of an older woman suffering dementia. The photos

were taken by one of her close relatives. The

service provider’s staff acted entirely appropriately in

seeking to prevent the photographs being taken.

They then referred the matter to CSCI, the police and

the local authority adult protection unit.

No one appears to be responding as one would

hope.

What would have been the reaction of those people if

the photographs had been taken by a father of his,

say, 15 year old daughter? Inaction is not an option.

Parliament

18.02.08 – HoC – Health and Social Care Bill,

remaining stages

20.02.08 – HoL - Viscount Falkland to ask

Government what steps it proposes to take to support

the training of disabled people on computers in their

own homes.

Next

Abuse

1. Parents get right to check on paedophiles

17 February 2008 - The Mail on Sunday

Paedophile check trials launched

16 January 2008 – BBC News

Trials will begin in June 2008 of what has come to be

known as ‘Sarah’s Law’ (a version of the USA’s

Megan’s Law) will allow parents to conduct background

checks with the police on people who will

have unsupervised contact with children.

The new procedures will be piloted in Cambridgeshire,

Cleveland, Hampshire and Warwickshire.

For BBC report click here

2. Woman, 94, died from neglect

15 February 2008 - The Times

Four weeks in a care home turned our

mother into a concentration camp victim

15 February 2008 - Daily Mail

Woman, 94, 'died after neglect'

14 February 2008 – BBC News

For full report see Older People—item 80

3. Protection agency staff ‘left children at

risk from abuse’ because of errors

15 February 2008 - The Times

How bungling social workers are putting

children’s lives at risk

15 February 2008 - Daily Mail

In Ofsted’s first report into the Children and Family

Court Advisory Service (Cafcass), East Midlands, it

concluded that dozens of children are at risk of

abuse because of ‘serious failings’ in Cafcass which

has cost £100m. For example, where safeguarding

issues were identified Cafcass had not checked that

child protection teams were aware of the situation.

Additionally, there were bizarre statements and

too much opinion and very little evidence.

An example of the bizarre; an 11 month old was said

to be too young to appreciate “the political significance

of his circumstance

4. Abused baby might have lived if 30 staff

had done their job

14 February 2008 - The Times

5. 30 health workers saw Jessica 10 times in

her 54 day life. So why was this sadist able

to kill her?

14 February 2008 - Daily Mail

Agencies 'failed' murdered baby

13 February 2008 – BBC News

Andrew Randall, 33, has been jailed for life for the

abuse, torture and murder of his 54 day old daughter.

There was a ‘collective failure’ to initiate child

protection procedures. All PCT staff have been retrained

to identify child abuse.

For BBC report click here

6. Mobile firms to block child porn

11 January 2008 – BBC News

World-wide mobile ‘phone firms have launched a new

alliance aiming to block paedophiles from using

phones to send or receive child sexual abuse images.

The GSMA, the global association for mobile firms,

has launched the Mobile Alliance, and among

planned measures will be a block on mobile phone

access to websites which host abusive content.

For full report click here

Business News

7. The Sunday Times Buyout Track 100

17 February 2008

A listing of 100 companies with the fastest growing

profits backed with private equity. There are 10 companies

from the health and social care sector which

are featured:

15 James Hull Associates; dental practices

22 IDIS; pharmaceuticals supplier

44 Healthcare at Home; healthcare provider

47 Care Principals; mental healthcare

61 Castlebeck; specialist healthcare

70 Alliance Medical; medical imaging

71 Affinity Healthcare; healthcare provider

79 Clinical Solutions; medical software provider

83 Voyage; care home operator

97 Oasis Healthcare; dental practices

8. Qataris seek £1.3bn for Four Seasons

Health Care

17 February 2008 - The Telegraph

Paul Taylor of Qatari state-backed investment fund,

Three Delta, is believed to be negotiating the refinancing

of Four Seasons Healthcare bought last

year.

Three Delta must needs a new financial backer or to

negotiate fresh terms with its present bankers before

June 2008, failing which it faces having to make a

very substantial repayment to its current funders,

Credit Suisse.

9. Craegmoor auction?

17 February 2008 - The Telegraph

As a footnote to the above item

“•?Legal & General Ventures has appointed investment

bank NM Rothschild to oversee a prospective

auction of Craegmoor, a care homes business valued

at up to £400m.”

10. Health merger sewn-up

17 February 2008 – The Mail on Sunday

A £35m merger has taken place between Premier

Medical and Medico Legal Reporting – it is backed

by Nomura Private Equity and 3i. The combined

company will produce some 100,000 insurance and

employment medical reports annually.

11. Patientline

16 February 2008 - The Times

Patientline, the struggling hospital bedside ‘phone

supplier saw its shares fall further to 0.55pence –

now trading on just over a ha’penny each.

12. Southern Cross Healthcare Grp PLC

14 February 2008

Quarter 1, 2008 Interim Management Statement

Care home demand drives strong Q1 at Southern

Cross Healthcare - the largest provider of UK care

home services, reported its first Interim Management

Statement for the 16 week period ended 20

January 2008 ('Q1').

• Q1 revenue up 29.6% to £262.6m (2007:

£202.6m)

• Q1 Adjusted EBITDA up 61.1% to £18.2m

• Underlying occupancy rate in mature business

of 90.7% (2007: 91.4%)

• Bed capacity increased by 2,025 beds at 20

January 2008

• Additional banking facility of £30m agreed with

Barclays Bank to finance future developments

• Demand for UK care home services remains

strong

13. Integrated Dental Holdings

11 February 2008 - The Times

The investment bank Merrill Lynch has acquired a

majority shareholding in Integrated Dental Holdings,

Britain’s biggest chain of dental practices.

Care Homes

14. Care homes face possible closure

12 February 2008 – BBC News

Devon has five care homes that could close down as

part of the proposed revamp of care for the elderly.

The Shaw Healthcare Group was voted to take over

Devon County Council’s 26 care homes.

But Barnhaven in Bampton, Lydiate Lodge in Lynton

and Orchard Lea in Cullompton could close within 18

months and Tracey Vale in Bovey Tracey and Arthur

Roberts in Exeter could close within three to seven

years.

For full report click here

15. Green care home refusal

11 February 2008 – Thisisexeter.co.uk

East Devon District Council has turned down plans

for the first eco-friendly care home in England. The

council decided to refuse permission for the project at

Douglas Avenue, Exmouth.

For full report go to http://www.thisisexeter.co.uk/

displayNode.jsp?

nodeId=142329&command=displayContent&sourceNode=1423

24&contentPK=19837227&folderPk=79879&pNodeId=142334

Case Reports

Law Reports

16. Lambeth London Borough v (1) KK, (2)

DK, (3) X (by his Guardian) and (4) Y (by his

Guardian)

It was in the best interests of two children for the

court to order an adjournment of an application for a

care order so that one of the children could undergo

blood tests in order to help the court determine

whether injuries sustained were non-accidental and

caused by his parents.

17. Re: F (a child)

In care proceedings the finding that the mother had

intentionally killed her two children by suffocating

them was set aside where, in light of a re-appraisal of

the expert evidence, the cause of the deaths was

demonstrated to be unascertainable.

18. R (on the application of G) v Nottingham

City Council)

The separation of a newborn baby from his mother

was unlawful where there was no judicial sanction, no

suggestion that the mother posed a risk of exposing

him to immediate physical attack or physical harm

and no medical justification for the intervention.

Ed. This case has been subject of news items in

BHCR Vol 3, Issue 5, item 21.

Disciplinary cases

Nothing to report

Cases in the news

19. It’s love, says prison psychiatrist having

mental patient’s baby

14 February 2008 - Daily Mail

Psychologist Stephanie Reeves, 30, received a 12

month suspended jail sentence for her ‘grave breach

of trust’ in engaging in sexual intercourse with a 20

year old mental patient who is in a secure unit as a

result of a series of offences. Reeves is pregnant as

a result. She has been ordered to sign the sex offenders

register.

20. Nurse left OAPs for water fights

11 January 2008 – BBC News

Michelle Bache, 39, faced seven misconduct charges

and sacked admitted leaving elderly patients alone

while she had water fights with other staff. The hearing

was told she was “overwhelmed professionally”

whilst left in charge at Bodawen Nursing Home in

Porthmadog, Gwynedd.

For full report click here

21. Care home criticised over woman's death

9 February 2008 – Sunderland Echo

Derek Winter, ruled that the Village Care Home in

South Hylton was guilty of a “gross failure” to provide

medical care for a 95-year-old woman. The coroner

severely criticised the care home at the end of the

two-day inquest and said he would report it to a national

watchdog.

For full report go to http://www.sunderlandecho.com/news/

Care-home-criticised-over-womans.3762044.jp

Children

Nothing to report

Conferences & Courses

22. Retirement Housing - One Day Conference,

27th February 2008

Thistle City Barbican, London, EC1

10.00 Surveying the market for retirement housing

including demographic trends across

the market

Barbara Laing, Managing Director - Housing Services,

Anchor Trust

10.30 Exploring opportunities in the growth of

Retirement Villages in the UK

Nick Sanderson, CEO, Raven Audley

11.30 Analysing the impact of retirement housing

on the wider residential market

Jim Ward, Head of Residential Research, Savills

12.00 Charting the growth of supply in luxury

retirement properties and challenges for

existing and new market entrants

Anthony Oldfield, Senior Associate, Healthcare, King

Sturge LLP

12.30 Exploring housing policy and partnerships

for retirement property development

Mark Wagstaff, Policy Advisor, Housing Corporation

14.00 Focusing on lending and finance for retirement

housing and the emergence of

specialist finance including mortgages,

tax, and equity

Paul Moran, Area Director - Head of Healthcare,

Bank of Ireland

14.30 Managing land acquisition and planning

strategies for retirement property

Neil Rowley MRTPI, Associate Director, Commercial

Planning, Savills

15.30 Evaluating marketing strategies to reach

retirement property customers

Martin James, Director, Retirement Homesearch

16.00 Case Study - St George’s Park Augustinian

Living – working with community

stakeholders to create added value in retirement

living

Philip Smith, Marketing Director, Augustinian Living

FAX the completed form to +44 (0) 20 7970 4799

Call +44 (0) 20 7970 4770

Book Online @ www.housing-strategy.com

Post a copy of this form together with your payment to

Centaur Conferences, 50 Poland Street, London, W1F

7AX

23. Voice08 - The UK conference for social

enterprise

Wednesday 27 February 2008

&

Young Voice08 -The UK conference for

young minds with social ambition

Tuesday 26 February 2008

Voice has changed.

We asked YOU what kind of conference you would

like and based on your responses we’ve designed

our most stimulating and interactive event yet.

We have exciting plenary and breakout sessions

scheduled (details below), including debates and

unprecedented levels of audience participation.

And unlike traditional conferences, delegates at

Voice08 also have the power to create their own sessions

by using our unique Make a Meeting service.

Just write your ideal discussion topic on a sign and

as soon as you have enough takers we’ll give you a

room. So go ahead and Pick Up A Placard!

Or you can wander into one of our many inspirational

igloos and speak to business experts, educators,

Social Enterprise Ambassadors and others.

If you think you have what it takes to set up your own

social enterprise then enter the replica elevator and

deliver a snappy elevator pitch to get expert feedback

and the chance to win a cash prize.

We will also be putting on a large exhibition and

trade fair which will run throughout the day, where

corporate exhibitors have offered to give delegates

one-on-one surgeries on key topics such as finance

and legal issues.

And to celebrate Liverpool’s European Capital of Culture

status there is going to be live music and cultural

performances, giant Beatles puppets and a fairtrade

fashion show.

So what are you waiting for? Register now

PROGRAMME

12.30 Welcome

13.15 Opening: YoungVoice

Jonathan Bland, Chief Executive, Social Enterprise

Coalition

Tim Campbell, Founder, Bright Ideas Trust

Phil Hope MP, Minister for Third Sector,

Cabinet Office

13.45 Interactive exhibition

Workshops (running simultaneously)

Sport & Social Enterprise

Mandy Young Adrenaline Alley

Media & Marketing for budding Social Entrepreneurs

Tokunbo Ajasa-Oluwa Catch 22

Sam Conniff Livity

Fashion, Music & Arts: The Social Enterprise

advance

Matt Kepple Wahblo

Trisha Lee Make Believe Arts

Social Enterprise Solutions for the Environment

Kresse Wessling EAKO

Amy Carter Bespoke Experience

Global Solutions: The Social Enterprise Approach

Gib Bulloch Accenture

Social Enterprise & Education

Young Co-operatives

ECO Schools initiative

16.00 Closing Address

Make your mark in 60 seconds – Tim Campbell

& Mark Bowness

16.30 – 17.00 Closing Concert

24. Children Missing Education Conference

Tuesday 26th February 2008 – Central London

We also have spaces still available on this practical

and informative event which is CPD Certified and

supported by the National Youth Agency. Please

click here to download a full conference brochure.

Chaired by Heather Stevens, Head of Policy, National

Youth Agency, our expert speakers include:

Joe Colleran, Regional Implementation Coordinator

– West Midlands, DCSF

Margaret Wood, Team Manager, Team for Traveller

Education, Cambridgeshire Race Equality and Diversity

Service, Cambridgeshire County Council

Maria McCann, Branch Head, CME Scotland, Scottish

Government

Shaklil Zaman, Principal Officer, Children Missing

Education Team, Sheffield City Council

Places can be booked on this event either by filling

out and returning the booking form on the final page

of the conference brochure, or by e-mailing the delegate

details directly to dave.eastman@capita.co.uk.

Alternatively you can book online by clicking here and

using Booking Reference Code TSDE.

25. ICHA Annual Conference : Investing in

Children

The intelligent use of residential child care

Wednesday 27 February 2008, Regent’s College

Conference Centre, London

The ICHA Annual Conference, organised in partnership

with CareandHealth will provide a unique opportunity

to explore with providers and commissioners

why investment in high quality residential care for

children must be sustained and developed and to

consider the impact of the plans laid out in Care Matters:

Time for Change White Paper and the new legislation

in the Children in Care Bill.

The conference will also allow providers for residential

care to consider with Local Authority senior managers

and commissioners how to ensure they can

help meet the challenge of ensuring that every child

in care has the 'right placement' and is able to experience

both stability and also the continuity of relationships

which, together, can lead to succesful outcomes.

Speakers include:

Christine Gilbert - Chief Inspector of Ofsted, Kevin

Brennan, Minister at DCFS, Andrew Christie - Director

of Children's Services, London Borough of Hammersmith

and Fulham and ADCS lead on Care Matters,

Jonathan Stanley, Principal Officer at the National

Centre for Excellence in Residential Care,

Benni-Jo Tyler - A National Voice.

Chair for first session: David Kidney - Chair of All

Party Parliamentary Group on Children in Care.

For more details go to www.careandhealth.com

Email: conferences@careandhealth.com

Tel: 0845 055 9207

Fax: 0871 901 7774

26. Extracare Housing - One Day Conference

- 28th February 2008

Thistle City Barbican, London, EC1

10.00 Surveying the market for extracare provision

and niche opportunities for the independent

sector

David Driscoll, CEO, Signature Senior Lifestyle

10.30 Reviewing partnerships and funding in extracare

housing projects

David Weiss, Head of Partnerships and Property,

Kent Adult Social Services

11.30 Health and social care partnerships in extracare

provision

Trevor Edwards, Housing LIN, Department of Health

12.00 Choices in Long Term Care

Sue Collins, Principal Policy and Public Affairs Manager,

Joseph Rowntree Foundation

Charting the trends and gaps in the development

of extracare housing supply

Tom Whittington, Head of Healthcare Research,

Savills

14.00 Designing sustainable extracare housing

Anne-Marie Nicholson, Director, PRP Architects

14.30 Developing medicare and extracare assistive

technology in housing

Denise Gillie, Associate, Care Services Improvement

Partnership, Department of Health

15.30 Promoting total care concepts including

self support, independent living and well

being in extracare services

Sarah Vallelly, Research Manager, Housing 21

16.00 Developing Sustainable Retirement Communities

Simon Evans, Senior Research Fellow, Health Training

& Research Centre, University of the West of

England

FAX the completed form to +44 (0) 20 7970 4799

Call +44 (0) 20 7970 4770

Book Online @ www.housing-strategy.com

Post a copy of this form together with your payment to

Centaur Conferences, 50 Poland Street, London, W1F

7AX

27. Skills for Care Annual Conference 2008

Wednesday 28 February

This year’s Skills for Care Annual Conference will be

held on Wednesday 28 February 2008 at the East

Midlands Conference Centre in Nottingham.

You can book online here or reserve your place by

phone on 0870 890 1080.

Given the title Turning Social Care on its Head – Developing

the workforce for personalised social care

services, it will look at the creation of a coherent approach

to the development of the social care workforce.

It will include keynote speakers and round table discussions

as well as an extensive exhibition including

leading training providers, staff agencies, publishers

and organisations offering qualifications.

28. RCN Independent Nurse Managers Forum

Conference: Improving practice...

improving care

The RCN will be holding a conference on Saturday 8

March 2008 at Cowdray Hall, RCN Headquarters,

London. The conference will examine the evolution

in the provision of health care and how independent

providers can look for ways to better assist the community

they serve. For further information please

contact the organiser: Guillia Ward; independent@

rcn.org.uk or visit www.rcn.org.uk/events

29. Capita’s 4th National

Data Sharing Across the Public Sector Conference

Practical Strategies for Success

Thursday 13th March 2008 – Central London

30. Plus A Half-Day Workshop

Data Sharing – Tackling the Challenges of

Consent and Confidentiality

Friday 14th March 2008 – Central London

Please note that we are now taking bookings on

these popular events, which are CPD Certified

and include contributions from the CESG and

the Information Commissioner’s Office. I would be

grateful if you could find the time to read this and

also forward it on to colleagues to whom it may be

relevant, especially those involved in Freedom of

Information, Data Protection and Information Management,

so that all stakeholders are given the opportunity

to attend this important event.

Receive a 20% Discount for attending both events.

Please click here for further details of these conferences.

If you have any problems with the hyperlink,

please e-mail me at dave.eastman@capita.co.uk

and I will send the brochure as an attachment.

Capita’s key gathering of policymakers and practitioners

will tackle all sides of the complex and, at times,

controversial data sharing policies and issues. Real

examples of how data sharing is evolving across all

areas of the public sector will inspire and provide you

with invaluable knowledge and guidance to take back

to your organisation.

Chaired by Penny Hill, Information Strategy Manager

of Social Care, Warwickshire County Council and

Board Member of National Information Governance

Board of Health and Social Care, our expert speakers

include:

· Stephen McCartney, Head of Data Protection

Promotion, ICO

· Rosemary Jay, Partner, Pinsent Masons,

· Craig Pollard, Head of Partner Development,

CESG

· Michael Eaton, Director of e-Wales & Head of

Public Sector Broadband Aggregation, Welsh Assembly

Government

· Helen Miriam, e-CAF Co-ordinator, Wandsworth

Council

Benefits of Attending include:

Learn how the ICO’s new framework Code of Practice

can benefit your organisation

Gain expert legal advice on privacy and confidentiality

issues and understand the use of privacy impact

assessments

Improve your understanding of information sharing

developments within Children’s Services

Explore network aggregation - linking local authorities

and the health sector

Places can be booked on these events either by filling

out and returning the booking form on the final page

of the conference brochure, or by e-mailing the delegate

details directly to dave.eastman@capita.co.uk.

Alternatively you can book online by clicking here and

using Booking Reference Code TSDE.

THE BOOKING REFERENCE CODE IS TSDE. YOU

MUST QUOTE THIS WHEN BOOKING.

31. Mental Capacity Act Training

National Care Association is providing a number of

training courses around the country. Each course is

free of charge and open to all, including nonmembers

of NCA.

Speakers include, Nadra Ahmed, Keith Lewin, Sheila

Scott and others. The next three courses will take

place as follows:

Bath Racecourse, Bath on Tuesday 18th March 2008

12.30pm - 5.00pm

Leeds University, Leeds on Wednesday 26th March

2008 – 12.30pm - 5.00pm

32. Capita’s 3rd National

Early Intervention for Families At-Risk Conference

Tackling Exclusion and Supporting Change

Friday 28th March 2008 – Central London

Please note that we are now taking bookings on this

popular event, which is CPD Certified and supported

by the NCH and the Children’s Workforce Development

Council. I would be grateful if you could find

the time to read this and also forward it on to colleagues

to whom it may be relevant, especially those

involved in Children’s and Adult Social Work, Family

Intervention, Social Inclusion and Safeguarding Children,

so that all stakeholders are given the opportunity

to attend this important event.

Please click here for further details of this conference.

If you have any problems with the hyperlink,

please e-mail me at dave.eastman@capita.co.uk and

I will send the brochure as an attachment.

Chaired by Angela Sibson, Chief Executive Officer,

National Academy of Parenting Practitioners, our

expert speakers include:

Gill Strachan, Assistant Director, Families Group,

DCSF

Graham Robb, Interim Chair, Youth Justice Board

Hilary Ellam, National Development Manager for

Integrated Working, Children’s Workforce Development

Council

Leandra Box, Strengthening Families, Strengthening

Communities Programme Director, Race Equality

Foundation

The Think Family report, published by the Social

Exclusion Task Force in January 2008, has launched

a comprehensive Early Intervention strategy uniting

services for children, young people, parents and

families to improve outcomes for all.

Attend this event to gain valuable ideas and help parents

in your communities realise and even raise their

expectations of themselves and their children. Benefit

from the opportunity to network with other stakeholders

who share your commitment to delivering an

holistic birth to adult inclusion programme.

Benefits of Attending:

Hear a clear overview of cross-Government strategy

on promoting strong family and community relationships

Discover how parenting support programmes can be

used as an effective Early Intervention tool to redress

entrenched inter-generational problems and increase

uptake of vital public services

Attend dedicated streamed sessions with experts in

your field

Places can be booked on this event either by filling

out and returning the booking form on the final page

of the conference brochure, or by e-mailing the delegate

details directly to dave.eastman@capita.co.uk.

Alternatively you can book online by clicking here and

using Booking Reference Code TSDE.

33. Action on Elder Abuse National Conference

‘Making Changes’ – 31st March & 1st April

University of Warwick

Action on Elder Abuse will be hosting its fifteenth 2

day National Conference in 2008, and it is set to be a

major event in the Health and Social Care calendar.

With a keynote speech by Ivan Lewis, Parliamentary

under-Secretary of State, and speakers to include:

Dru Sharpling, Crown Prosecution Service

Ronnie Monks, Department of Health

Richard Brook, Office of the Public Guardian

Representatives from the Association of Chief

Police Officers and the Healthcare Commission

Workshops will include subjects on:

Hate crime

Deprivation of liberty

Financial abuse

Review of ‘No Secrets’

Domestic violence, elder and vulnerable adult

abuse

Learning Disabilities and Safeguarding Adults

£220 + VAT for members

£255 + VAT for non-members

A full, detailed programme and booking form will be

available shortly, but to register your interest and request

a booking form, please contact Natalie Fernandez

on natalie@elderabuse.org.uk

34. Department of Health Seminar on Mental

Health Commissioning: 7 May 2008

This letter gives advance notice of a one-day seminar

on 7 May 2008 at the Victoria Park Plaza Hotel in

London, focusing on world-class commissioning, integrated

mental health commissioning and mental

health priorities.

For full report click here

Consultations

To follow next week

CSCI, CSSIW, Healthcare

Commission &

Scottish Care Commission

35. Worthing care home gets all-clear

13 February 2008 - The Argus

Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI) obtained

an order for the urgent cancellation of the registration

of Trevine Court at the end of last year. Service

users were forcibly removed and relocated elsewhere.

Now it appears that CSCI had no proper basis for the

application. The owner of the home, Sean Adelphie,

appealed the cancellation order, at the hearing of his

appeal surprisingly CSCI did not offer any evidence.

He has accused CSCI of being ‘trigger

happy’ and says he will sue for loss of profits for the

period of six months that the home was closed.

36. Hospital opens to new admissions

11 January 2008 – BBC News

Whipton Hospital, in Exeter, has re-opened to new

patients after stopping admissions while investigations

took place into alleged substandard nursing

care claims.

For full report click here

See previous story in BHCR Vol 3, Issue 6—item 44.

Education

37. Every child in school numbered for life

13 February 2008 - The Times

Anger over pupils database plan

13 February 2008 – BBC News

The Government plans that all 14 yr old children will

be allocated another number unique to them to be

known as a Unique Learner Number (ULN) which

they will have throughout their adult lives to provide a

‘tamper-proof CV’ including details of qualifications,

school exclusions etc.

For BBC report click here

Ed. What an appalling idea. Yet more Big

Brother-ism. Yet another opportunity for the Government

to squander cash on another crack-pot

idea. Yet another opportunity to compromise our

personal information, to loose it and have it stolen

and have it corrupted.

Who ever came up with what to many will seem a

hair-brained scheme take 1000 lines…

Ireland, Scotland & Wales

Ireland

38. Minister may hold C. diff inquiry

16 January 2008 – BBC News

Health Minister Michael McGimpsey has indicated

that he is prepared to hold a public inquiry into the

current Clostridium difficile outbreak. But he said he

will only do so after an independent review into the

Northern Trust outbreak is complete.

The hospital infection was recorded on the death certificates

of 77 people last year - 34 in the Northern

area.

For full report click here

39. Patient record in charity cabinet

13 February 2008 – BBC News

A patient’s medical file has been found in a filing cabinet

that was sold in a charity shop. A man bought the

cabinet for £25 and found the file wedged under a

jammed drawer. The file was passed to Antrim councillor,

Drew Ritchie, who handed it over to the Northern

Health and Social Care Trust.

The Trust said it would investigate.

For full report click here

40. Trust bosses quizzed over C. diff

12 February 2008 – BBC News

Northern Ireland’s five health trust chiefs will be questioned

about the outbreak of the hospital bug clostridium

difficile and to find out how the problem is being

tackled.

The chief executives will be asked about the number

of cases in their areas as well.

For full report click here

Scotland

41. Hospital parking cap introduced

17 January 2008 – BBC News

A cap has been announced for car parking in the

Glasgow area can charge for parking. A £3 maximum

charge per day has been introduced after a review

of parking fees, ordered by Health Secretary

Nicola Sturgeon. Before the review, car parks at

Gartnavel, Yorkhill, the Western and the Victoria were

charging up to £7 per day before the move.

For full report click here

42. Scotland To Give War Veterans Priority

On NHS

15 February 2008 – The Herald

Scottish health secretary Nicola Sturgeon has announced

that it was "only fair" that veterans with

health problems as a result of their time in the Armed

Forces should receive priority treatment in the NHS.

43. Anger at woman's transfer ordeal

13 February 2008 – BBC News

The Scottish Ambulance Service is calling for more

funding for patient transport after it took eight hours

to transfer a 94-year-old woman between two hospitals.

Violet Lunan was angry that she had to wait at Raigmore

Hospital for 5 hours and then endure a 3 hour

journey in a minibus.

An ambulance spokesman also said the patient pickup

was made within the specified timescale.

For full report click here

44. £15m boost for medical research

12 February 2008 – BBC News

Funding of nearly £15.5m has been announced for

medical research which could create up to 100 jobs

in Scotland, to support 39 research projects. The

projects will cover areas such as cardiovascular and

metabolic disease and women's health.

For full report click here

45. Woman waits an hour for ambulance

12 February 2008 – BBC News

The Scottish Ambulance Service (SAS) has been

forced to defend its response times after an elderly

woman had to wait over an hour for an emergency

service after being diagnosed as life-threatening.

The SAS claimed it was "very rare" for such a delay

with latest figures showing the average response time

in Tayside was currently 8.6 minutes.

Dundonians have the shortest average wait at 7.4

minutes, while Pitlochry locals face the longest wait of

11.4 minutes.

For full report click here

Wales

46. Hospital £33m telemedicine boost

15 February 2008 – BBC News

Welsh hospitals are set to receive a share of almost

£33m to buy new equipment to use on technologies

such as telemedicine.

Money will also go towards Magnetic Resonance Imaging

(MRI) scanners, x-ray machines and endoscopy

machines. The money will also be used for

minor building work and help hospitals to reduce energy

consumption.

For full report click here

47. 999 staff critical over changes

15 February 2008 – BBC News

A survey of Welsh Ambulance Service workers

shows that the workers do not believe its changes

have been handled well.

The NHS poll was leaked to BBC Wales and found

that two in three employees didn’t think that senior

managers were being “open and honest” with them

either.

For full report click here

48. Fear for care home staff shortage

14 February 2008 – BBC News

Stephen Crabb, MP for Preseli Pembrokeshire is

warning of a potential shortage of care home staff in

Wales if Filipino workers are deported under new

laws.

Home Office regulations are aimed at better qualifications

and pay and state that staff must earn an hourly

wage of at least £7.02 to be able to gain work permits.

For full report click here

Learning Disabilities

49. Valuing People Now consultation success,

as Greig signals departure

13 February 2008 – Community Care

Rob Greig, the national co-director of learning disabilities,

has announced that he will step down from

his role in April.

The announcement came as it was revealed that unprecedented

numbers of people with learning disabilities

have joined the consultation on the revised learning

disability document, Valuing People Now.

For full report click here

Legislation Update

Nothing to report

Mental Health

50. Mental health unit under threat

14 February 2008 – BBC News

Lea Castle Hospital in Wolverley, Worcestershire is

currently under threat as officials debate its future.

The hospital treats people with mental illness but is

currently making losses of “literally thousands of

pounds each day” as quoted by Dr Richard Taylor,

MP for Wyre Forest.

For full report click here

51. Government needs to address ongoing

problem of violence on psychiatric wards,

says Mental Health Foundation

14 February 2008 - Mental Health Foundation

Responding to Healthcare Commission report on

violence in mental health services, the charity’s Director

of Mental Health Programmes, Kathryn Hill,

said:

“The government needs to address the ongoing

problem of violence of psychiatric wards in England

and Wales. Patient attacks, not only on staff but on

other patients too should not be common place in

settings where people go to receive care and treatment.

“There are a number of reasons why violence is so

prevalent on mental health wards. One is that patients

are bored and frustrated because there is nothing

to do – they often feel abandoned and not listened

to.”

Kathryn Hill also says that nurses on mental health

wards, while fully qualified, often have very little experience

of working with patients because they are

assigned to work in psychiatric units immediately

after their training.

“So we’ve got a situation where the least experienced

staff members are working with severely unwell

and disturbed patients in overcrowded environments.

Staff need specialised support and guidance

to help care for patients.”

The Mental Health Foundation also says that urgent

action needs to be taken to develop interventions to

tackle violence on wards for those over the age of 65

with dementia.

52. Healthcare Commission report highlights

the need to review resources in Mental

Health services

13 February 2008 - ECCA

The English Community Care Association responded

to the Healthcare Commission report on violence towards

staff in mental health facilities.

Martin Green, Chief Executive of ECCA, said:

“The report raises a number of very important issues

and in particular highlights that the policy to keep

people in the community means that the dependency

levels and challenges of those who require residential

services are increased. Sadly, the system has not

recognised this in the way it resources or equips services

to meet these complex needs”.

“If we are going to develop flexible, user-focused and

outcome based services that meet the expectations

of society and the needs of users we need to put residential

care higher up the agenda”.

53. 50% of mental health nurses assaulted

13 February 2008

Mental health nurses face attacks

13 February 2008 – BBC News

An audit carried out by the Royal College of Psychiatrists

for the Healthcare Commission found that more

than 50% of nurses on mental health wards have

been physically assaulted at work.

For BBC report click here

54. Nick Clegg calls for revolution in mental

health services

8 February 2008 – Community Care

Nick Clegg, LibDem leader is calling for a “revolution”

in mental health services. He said the sector needs

to reduce excessive assessment and lengthy waiting

times.

For full report click here

Miscellaneous

55. Publication of Clostridium Difficile surveillance

data

15 February 2008 – DoH

A letter from the Inspector of Microbiology that sets

out the department’s plans for publication of Clostridium

Difficile data in April and July 2008.

For full report click here

56. Doctors' leaders under the cosh

14 February 2008 – BBC News

GPs in impossible position - BMA

11 February 2008 – HSJ

GPs have accepted an option from the Department of

Health that will see practices open for a further 30

minutes a week for each 1,000 registered patients,

despite feeling they have been put in an impossible

position, the BMA has said.

All GPs are set to be balloted on the move later this

month.

For BBC report click here

57. NHS Payout Highlights Continuing Care

Problems

13 February 2008 - ECCA

The English Community Care Association responded

to the news that the NHS is to pay back £180 million

that was denied people with long-term care needs

between 1996 and 2004.

Martin Green, Chief Executive of ECCA, said:

“This payout has brought into sharp focus the issue of

NHS payments for long-term conditions. There is a

need for the NHS to shoulder its responsibility for

health issues and to ensure that the care sector is

properly resourced to deliver care and support to

people with long-term conditions”.

“The mistakes that were made in the past will mean

less money in an already pressurised system and we

must ensure that the resources which are required to

deliver care for the increasing numbers of older and

sick people who require long-term support are available”.

58. Health effects of climate change in the

UK 2008: an update of the Department of

Health report 2001/2002

12 February 2008 – DoH

A DH-commissioned report has been written by a

group of independent scientists, which updates their

earlier report on the health effects of climate change,

published in 2001/2002.

A draft version of the report was originally launched

for comment on 4 May 2007. Comments received

may be viewed in the original article that can be accessed

through the hyperlink below.

For full report click here

59. New work programme for NICE

11 February 2008 - GNN

The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence

(NICE) has been asked to develop new clinical

and public health guidance as part of its 15th work

programme.

The Institute's technology appraisal, clinical guideline

and public health work programmes are referred by

the Department of Health. Topics for referral include

both new and emerging health technologies as well

as drugs, devices and procedures that are already

being used but there is variation in the way they are

used.

Dawn Primarolo, the Minister with responsibility for

Public Health and NICE said:

"This work programme shows the Government's continued

commitment to ensuring that NICE tackles a

wide range of issues that are important to the NHS

and important to patients and their carers.

"NICE is being asked to produce guidance on severe

mental illness in conjunction with substance misuse.

We have also asked NICE to develop joint public

health and clinical guidance on alcohol use disorders

that will not only cover prevention and early identification

but also initial management.”

60. GPs dismayed

11 February 2008 - The Times, Letters to the Editor

From a newly qualified GP, Dr Elizabeth Phillips, who

says patients do not want polyclinics or extended

opening hours, but the holistic, quality care of a doctor

who knows them.

61. Patient choice

March 2008 - Which?, Your letters

Letter from Dr Cornel Fleming who complains that as

a result of central dictat from the Department of

Health his practice has had to move from open access

for patients to a mixture of fixed appointments

and open access. He does not support the polyclinics

approach which he has seen in Russia where

Russian doctors and patients are jealous of the UK

practices.

62. National Care Association Attends Health

Care Event in Portugal

8 February 2008 - NCA

NCA took the opportunity at the prestigious Health

Care Event in Portugal to highlight the challenges

facing health and social care providers in the coming

year.

Its presentation at the event reflected the frustrations

of providers within the sector at the relentless pace of

change. Sheila Scott OBE, Chief Executive of NCA

highlighted specific initiatives in the sector and she

said: “The Health and Social Care Bill currently going

through Parliament will for the first time allow opportunities

for providers to develop their services to provide

a flexible resource within the communities in

which they operate.”

NCA strongly reinforced its concerns about the implementation

and implications of Star Rating for providers

in the light of the inconsistent approach by individual

inspectors. Nadra Ahmed OBE, Chairman of

NCA said: “NCA is committed to ensuring that any

change in process must benefit service users and to

this end we have today begun consulting on issues

such as star rating. We are certain that if there is not

a consistent approach the impact of such initiatives

on small business and indeed on all providers could

be critical.

NCA Continues to question whether CSCI has the

power to introduce a new set of standards.

The consultation process will continue at a series of

seminars NCA is organising in the next two months.”

NHS

63. One-stop clinics 'are the future'

16 January 2008 – BBC News

Health Minister, Lord Darzi, has said that clinics

manned by a single doctor should be replaced by

one-stop health shops, to be run by several GPs.

Lord Darzi said that so-called 'polyclinics', which

house GPs alongside medical services normally offered

at hospitals, are better suited to patients' needs

and has proposed them for London. He also said it

would work across England.

For full report click here

64. 'Super surgery' plans condemned

16 January 2008 – BBC News

Doctors and patients' groups are criticising proposals

by health minister Lord Darzi to reorganise the English

GP system (see article above).

For full report click here

65. Super-surgeries: for and against

16 January 2008 – BBC News

Article looking at both sides of Lord Darzi’s suggestion

that individual GP surgeries should be replaced

by bigger centres known as polyclinics has had a

mixed reception.

For full report click here

66. Long A&E waits rise

16 February 2008 - The Times

Casualty waiting times soar after cut in

emergency beds

16 February 2008 - Daily Mail

Stats press notice – A&E statistics

15 February 2008 - GNN

Waiting times in A&E units increased by more than

55% at the end of 2007 as hospitals cut emergency

beds. However, 97% were seen within the Government’s

four hour target.

The link for the stats is at : http://

www.performance.doh.gov.uk/hospitalactivity/

data_requests/index.htm

67. Patient data laptop stolen

15 February 2008 - The Times

Medical records laptop is stolen

14 February 2008 – BBC News

The Dudley Group of Hospitals NHS Trust is the latest

to loose patient data; a laptop containing the

medical records of 5,123 patients has been stolen

from the outpatient’s department of Russells Hall

Hospital.

For BBC report click here

68. Throat cancer patient ‘starved to death’

after feeding tube blunder

15 February 2008 - The Times

An inquest in November 2007 found that Roy Hodgson,

66, died in Cumberland Infirmary after his feeding

tube became which went into his stomach came

out and was reinserted wrongly by a nurse. It resulted

in the liquid nourishment which went through

the tube went not into his stomach but his abdominal

cavity poisoning him.

The NHS Litigation Authority now accepts liability for

the death.

69. Help the Aged respond to NHS £180m

payout

14 February 2008 – NCF

Mervyn Kohler of Help the Aged said:

'The whole system of continuing care has been a

terrible mess.

People are being forced to navigate their way through

a confusing and inaccessible system of funding, at a

time when a tangle of red tape is the last thing they

need.

This is why it is so pleasing to see people getting their

money back.”

For full report click here

70. NHS changes 'are yet to deliver'

14 February 2008 – BBC News

A spending watchdog has called for NHS hospitals to

deliver significant improvements. Reforms designed

to reward such improvements, “Payment by Results”

shows that productivity has not risen greatly.

Under the scheme, trusts get a national fixed price for

treatments regardless of how much they cost to provide

but doctors said the scheme may have

“interfered with clinical judgement”.

For full report click here

71. Warning for hospitals

14 Feb 2008 The Times

The Audit Commission has said that high-cost hospitals

could go ‘bust’ unless they become more efficient.

Apparently, payment by results has not had

any appreciable effect on efficiency.

72. NHS private clinics 'underused'

13 February 2008 – BBC News

Private clinics are still being paid even though they

are not seeing as many patients as they should be,

because their income was guaranteed. Private treatment

centres were originally set up to do minor surgery

and run diagnostic tests to cut NHS waiting lists.

Recent figures show that just four of the 25 such clinics

created in the first wave of openings are doing

enough work. In response, the Government said the

clinics would be making up the shortfall in work in the

future.

For full report click here

73. NHS faces £180m overcharging bill

12 February 2008 – BBC News

The NHS has received a £180m compensation bill

after it incorrectly charged people for long-term nursing

and social care from 1996 to 2004. Patients

have been able to have their cases reviewed if they

felt they were overcharged and so has led to over

13,000 claims and 2,000 pay-outs.

The claims relate to the way different health authorities

charged for care needed because of illness, disability

and continuing NHS treatment.

For full report click here

74. New NHS dental places snapped up

13 February 2008 – BBC News

Sir Menzies Campbell has officially opened a new

NHS dental surgery covering the area of North East

Fife. The practice has already registered more than

600 new patients and will hopefully be up and running

in mid-March.

A Scottish company Partners in Progress opened the

centre after identifying a dire need for NHS dental

provision.

For full report click here

75. Faulty scales threat

13 February 2008 - The Times

Fears over faulty hospital scales

12 February 2008 – BBC News

Patients, particularly children, are at risk from faulty

weighing scales in hospitals where treatment is

geared to a person’s weight. Trading standards officers

from local councils will be making spot checks.

For BBC report click here

Ed. Why can’t the NHS get this basic stuff

right? It is more cost to society to deflect Trading

Standards Officers to carry out this work. I wonder

will we see any NHS Trusts prosecuted? We

can be sure that if there was a sale of underweight

produce by supermarkets they would be

prosecuted!

76. Statistical press notice: Diagnostic Test

waiting times

Diagnostics waiting times & activity data: month

ending December 2007

This data is said to show NHS progress is tackling

the waiting times for diagnostic tests like scans. The

monthly data published today gives the waiting times

for 15 key diagnostic tests carried out in the

NHS. This data will help the NHS in delivering the

new 18 week maximum wait from GP to treatment,

including all diagnostic tests, by end 2008. More

information, including a diagnostic data Q&A, is available

via the 18 week website.

Link to Diagnostic data: http://

www.performance.doh.gov.uk/diagnostics/index.htm

77. Health service reforms ‘in full retreat’

11 February 2008 - The Times

A report from Prof. Nick Bosanquet, Professor of

Health Policy at Imperial College London, says that

reform of the NHS is stalling and continues to fall behind

comparable countries in Europe.

Nursing

78. Nurse, learn how to smile!

12 February 2008 – Daily Mail

A training scheme is being pioneered in Stockport,

Greater Manchester to send nurses are on training

courses to encourage them to smile at patients.

Nurses will also be banned from discussing their personal

lives outside break times, or talking too loudly

at night when patients are trying to sleep.

Older People

79. DH: Nutrition and Dignity live webchat

Ivan Lewis MP and Gordon Lishman will be hosting a

live webchat for nutrition and dignity Champions on

20 Feb at 4pm at: www.publicquestion.com

80. Woman, 94, died from neglect

15 February 2008 - The Times

Four weeks in a care home turned our

mother into a concentration camp victim

15 February 2008 - Daily Mail

Woman, 94, 'died after neglect'

14 February 2008 – BBC News

Molly Darby, 94, was said to “look like a concentration

camp victim” a matter of weeks after she went into a

care home. She was transferred to hospital with

pressure ulcers, chest and ear infections and pneumonia.

She died. Rotherham social services has

said that the home was negligent following its investigation.

For BBC report click here

81. National Care Association supports the

findings of Age Concern Report

15 February 2008

National Care Association supports the findings of

the Age Concern Report Out of Sight, Out of Mind

reported in the national press.

NCA Chairman Nadra Ahmed OBE said: “Anyone

who works in social care and visits older people in

their own homes will recognise the observations in

this report. We fully support the view that assessment

should take into account the social and spiritual

needs of older people as well as their physical and

mental well being.

As we have repeatedly pointed out over the years

due to the financial pressures on local Government

many older people are denied the services they need

and deserve. The only way that this could be fairly

resolved, we believe, would be to introduce national

assessment criteria which could be easily understood

by all including service users themselves. It is

totally unacceptable in the twenty first century for

elderly people to be subject to a post code lottery.”

82. Care homes: restraint of elderly people is

rife

February 2008 - Counsel and Care

Writing about the recent CSCI report Rights, risks

and restraints, published November 2007, Stephen

Burke, chief executive of Counsel and Care said:

"It is not an easy discussion a delicate balance has

to be made between an older person's rights to take

risks and make autonomous decisions and their

families' and involved professionals' responsibility to

protect and keep them safe where possible.”

Social Care

83. Adults Social Care Workforce and Children's

Social Care Workforce Contributions

to Local Authorities' Area Based Grant

12 February 2008 – DoH

This circular aims to provide some clarity about

changes, from April 2008, to the grants to support

social care workforce training, development and remodelling.

For full report click here

Staff, employment and

disciplinary

Nothing to report

Stars in their eyes

In this article Keith Lewin considers, in a limited

way, some of the provisions of the new CSCI assessment

process and offers his views about

some of the ways care providers might be able to

restore the balance of power.

The Commission For Social Care Inspection (CSCI)

new Star Rating System, AQQA, KLORA, SOFI and

all the rest have been pushed through by the regulator,

mostly against the views and wishes of many of

the National and Local Associations representing the

interests of care providers – perhaps that is not altogether